Quick Answer
Getting a spine surgery second opinion means asking a different physician to weigh the same scans, symptoms and proposed operation before you agree to it. Second opinions typically recommend less surgery, a scoping review found, though long-term effects are unclear. For Columbia patients, the process at Synergy begins with a free MRI review at home.
Key Takeaways

- A second opinion checks whether the diagnosis fits your symptoms, whether surgery is needed now, and whether a smaller operation would do the same job.
- In a São Paulo study of 485 people advised to have spine surgery, just 15.5% heard the same surgical advice from the second doctor (Lenza and colleagues, 2017).
- Second opinions tend to recommend less surgery, but a scoping review found the long-term effect is still unclear and called for better trials.
- Synergy doesn’t perform fusion, and when instability, a significant slip or deformity makes fusion the right answer, patients are referred to qualified fusion surgeons.
- From Columbia, step one is a no-cost look at scans you’ve already had, and Seneca comes into it only if an in-person visit makes sense.
Weighing a surgery recommendation? Send the MRI you already have and get an independent read, free.
What does a spine surgery second opinion actually check?
A spine surgery second opinion checks three things: whether the diagnosis explains your symptoms, whether an operation is needed now, and whether the one proposed is the smallest that would do the job. It isn’t a contest between doctors. If you keep wondering, should I get a second opinion, you’re asking a sensible question, and Synergy’s second opinion page explains how the practice approaches it. It’s fair to know the practice’s perspective, too. Dr. McMillan’s work centers on full-endoscopic surgery without fusion, which our complete guide to endoscopic spine surgery describes. For Columbia patients, the first look costs nothing and needs no trip. You share the scans you’ve already had, and the answer comes back to you at home.
Surgical second opinion is a fresh, independent look at your diagnosis, images and planned operation by another physician, taken before you consent to surgery so two informed views can be compared.
How to ask without making it awkward
It’s natural to worry that asking will offend your surgeon. Seeking a second opinion on back surgery is a normal part of making a big decision, though, and you don’t have to switch doctors to get one. A short request works. You might say: Before I schedule, I’d like another review. Could your office send my imaging and your consultation note? Nothing about a second look says your first surgeon was wrong. Skilled surgeons can look at one MRI and reach different conclusions, as the research below shows, and you can still choose to have surgery with the first one. Synergy’s job is to give you an honest read of your own case, not to criticize anyone else’s.
Do second opinions lead to less surgery, and is that the same as better care?
Second opinions for spine surgery typically recommend less surgery and may reduce operations in the short term, but whether that improves long-term results is still unclear, according to a scoping review of 12 observational studies (Ferreira and colleagues, 2022). The same review found that agreement on the need for surgery between first and second opinions ranged from 0 to 83%. That’s a very wide spread, so no single figure tells you what your own second opinion will show. The authors called for better trials. Less surgery isn’t automatically better care. It’s better when the operation wasn’t needed, and worse when it was. The value of a second opinion is that it makes you ask that question on purpose. If worn discs are the reason surgery came up, degenerative disc disease treatment for Columbia patients covers where the evidence is thin.
485 patients, three numbers
Here’s what one large study found, in plain numbers. Researchers in São Paulo, Brazil, tracked 485 people who had been advised to have spine surgery and then got a second opinion through their insurance program (Lenza and colleagues, 2017). Roughly 6 in 10 of them (59.8%) left with a different diagnosis. About 1 in 6 (15.5%) heard the same surgical advice again. More than half (55.3%) were steered toward conservative care, meaning treatment without an operation. A study like this measures disagreement. It doesn’t score accuracy. A different recommendation is a starting point for questions, not a verdict. So if your second look disagrees with the first, the next move is to ask each surgeon to explain what the other one saw.
How does a remote MRI review work as the first stage of a second opinion?
Synergy’s free MRI review is the at-home half of the process. You submit the imaging and reports you already have, and they’re read against your symptoms. If you’d rather send physical copies, the practice explains MRI review by mail. The review can’t replace an exam, and all evaluation and treatment happen in person in Seneca. What it can do is tell you whether a visit is worth making.
The Problem
A surgeon has recommended a fusion for low back and leg pain. The reasoning made sense in the office, but questions came later at home. A drive to another surgeon feels like a lot to ask without knowing whether it’s worth it.
The Solution
The MRI images, radiology report and surgeon’s note go to Synergy through the free review. The review compares the findings with the symptoms you describe and looks for a pinched nerve a smaller operation could free, or signs that fusion is truly needed.
The Resolution
Either answer is useful. Sometimes the review supports the original plan. Sometimes it points to an in-person consultation in Seneca to discuss a no-fusion option. If you aren’t a candidate, you won’t be asked to travel.
With surgery on the calendar, what’s a sensible 90-day second-opinion plan for a Columbia patient?
Ninety days is a working window, not a rule. If your surgeon has said the operation is urgent, or you have any of the warning signs listed on this page, don’t wait on a review. For a planned operation, this outline keeps the second look moving without stalling your care.
Week one: gather records
Call your Columbia surgeon’s office and request three things: the MRI images, the radiologist’s report and the note that lays out the recommended surgery. Jot down what you’ve tried so far, from therapy to injections. Then send it all in through the free MRI review.
Next: the review’s answer
If the review supports your current plan, you can go ahead with more confidence. If it suggests a smaller option, the next step is an in-person consultation in Seneca. If neither fits, you’ll hear plainly what falls outside the practice’s scope.
Then decide, either way
Put the two opinions side by side and ask each surgeon what the other one sees. Then choose, knowing why. If you choose surgery in Seneca, the 3-day plan runs consultation, procedure and post-op check back to back.

Want to know whether a smaller, no-fusion operation could fit your problem? Start with a free look at your imaging.
What are the possible answers from a second opinion, and where does each one lead?
A second opinion doesn’t have one built-in outcome. It can agree, disagree or land somewhere in between, and each answer points to a different next step. The table sorts the main possibilities. It’s written from Synergy’s side, so it also says plainly when the practice isn’t the right place for you. That candor matters most for a spinal fusion second opinion, where the operation in question is the bigger one.
| If the second opinion finds | What it may mean | What happens next |
|---|---|---|
| The first plan fits the problem | Two physicians agree on the diagnosis and the operation | You go ahead with more confidence, with the surgeon you choose |
| A smaller operation could work | For example, freeing one pinched nerve instead of fusing two vertebrae | An in-person consultation in Seneca about full-endoscopic surgery |
| Surgery isn’t needed yet | Nonsurgical care deserves a fair try first, the advice 55.3% received in one large study (Lenza study) | Nonsurgical treatment, ideally with your own doctors in Columbia |
| Instability, a significant slip or deformity | Fusion may truly be the right answer | Referral to a qualified fusion surgeon, since Synergy doesn’t do fusion |
| The images don’t explain the pain | The source may lie elsewhere, or more testing is needed | A frank explanation of what the imaging can and can’t show |
Only one row ends with surgery at Synergy. That’s by design. A second opinion is only useful if the reviewer is willing to say your first surgeon got it right, or that you need an operation the practice doesn’t perform. Research on fusion helps frame the conversation. One study of U.S. fusion trends describes fusion as appropriate for deformity and instability, while support is thin when the problem is a herniated disc, or narrowing without any instability (Martin and colleagues, 2019). Ask both surgeons which group your spine falls into, and why.
What does the in-person part of a second opinion ask of someone driving from Columbia?
It asks for a day, more or less, and it never leaves South Carolina. The drive to Seneca is about 2½ to 3 hours, by I-26 to I-385, then US-123, and you only make it if the free review says an in-person visit is worthwhile. Flying out of CAE, Columbia’s airport, wouldn’t shorten anything, because its own drive to Seneca is just as long. Dr. McMillan, a Yale graduate who earned his MD at Tufts, is licensed in South Carolina. Census QuickFacts puts 11.5% of Columbia’s residents at 65 or older (U.S. Census Bureau, 2025). If you’re in that group, ask both surgeons the same question: how does this operation fit someone my age and health?
| Drive to the practice | About 2½ to 3 hours by car via I-26 to I-385, then US-123, depending on traffic and where you start. |
|---|---|
| Nearest major airport to Seneca | Greenville-Spartanburg International Airport (GSP), about an hour away by car. |
| From CAE | Columbia Metropolitan Airport is about 2½ to 3 hours from the practice by car. |
| Before you travel | Free MRI review of the imaging you already have. If you aren’t a candidate, you won’t be asked to travel. |
| Where you’ll be seen | Synergy Spine Center & Physician Group P.A., 457-E Bypass 123, Seneca, SC 29678 |
What to carry into the exam room
Bring the same records you sent for the review, plus your medicine list and the questions you most want answered. Write them down, because the ride home is a long time to remember the one you forgot. The initial consultation is $250, and the pricing note below explains how that’s handled. Nothing obliges you to decide on surgery at that visit. If you do choose an operation in Seneca, it follows the practice’s 3-day plan, with a companion to drive after sedation. Synergy’s page for Columbia patients is the place to start planning the drive.
About these prices. Bundled cash prices include the $250 initial consultation (credited to the surgeon fee if the procedure is performed), surgeon, anesthesia, facility and routine post-op follow-up. Pre-op labs, imaging, pathology and additional diagnostics are billed separately. If insurance is filed, these prices do not apply. Insurance is also accepted. Coverage depends on your plan; check before you book travel. Figures are the practice’s published 2026 rates. See the pricing disclaimer.
The Bottom Line
Asking for a second look is a check on a big decision, not a challenge to your surgeon. Research shows a second doctor’s recommendation can differ sharply from the first, though long-term effects remain unclear. From Columbia, starting costs nothing: submit your imaging for a free review, and make the drive only if it’s worth making.
A second look costs nothing to start. Send your imaging from Columbia and decide with more information.
Prefer to talk first? Call (833) 770-8100 toll-free.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the second opinion recommends more surgery than the first?
It can happen, because a second opinion follows the findings rather than a preference for less surgery, and sometimes the findings point to a bigger operation, such as a fusion for an unstable spine. Second opinions tend to lean toward less surgery, a scoping review found, but that’s a tendency, not a rule (Ferreira and colleagues, 2022). If the review sees instability, a significant slip or deformity, it will say so. Synergy doesn’t perform fusion, so you’d be referred to a qualified fusion surgeon. That answer is as valuable as any other, because it means your decision rests on what the images show.
How often do two surgeons agree that an operation is needed?
One scoping review of 12 observational studies found agreement on the need for surgery ranged anywhere from 0 to 83% (Ferreira and colleagues, 2022), a spread too wide to predict what your own second opinion will show. Observational studies watch what happens without controlling who gets which opinion, so they describe patterns but can’t prove cause. The authors called for better trials. In the meantime, the useful question isn’t how often surgeons agree in general. It’s whether the two surgeons looking at your MRI agree, and why or why not.
My surgery is already scheduled. Is it too late to get a second opinion?
It isn’t too late to ask for a second opinion on a planned operation, but talk with your surgeon’s office about timing before you cancel or move anything, and don’t delay care your surgeon calls urgent. The free MRI review can start right away with the imaging you already have. You can ask whether the date can hold while you get a second look. If you notice any of the warning signs listed on this page, go to an emergency department instead of waiting.
Does my health plan require or cover a second opinion?
That depends entirely on your plan, since some health plans have their own rules about second opinions and others don’t, so call the number on your card before you book anything. Synergy’s MRI review is free, so that step costs nothing either way. If an in-person visit follows, the initial consultation is $250 at cash prices. Insurance is also accepted. Cash prices don’t apply when insurance is billed. Coverage depends on your plan; check before you book travel.
Can a second opinion help if I’ve been offered a fusion for back pain alone?
Yes, that’s a situation where a spinal fusion second opinion is especially worth having, because research describes the evidence for fusion to treat back pain from disc degeneration as controversial (Martin and colleagues, 2019). The same study calls fusion appropriate for deformity and instability. Back pain without leg symptoms can come from several sources, including the facet joints, which a diagnostic block can test. Synergy’s chronic back pain page covers those other sources. If the review does find instability, fusion may still be right, and you’ll hear that too.
Can I fit the in-person visit into one day from Columbia?
A consultation-only visit from Columbia can sometimes fit in one long day, since the drive each way is about 2½ to 3 hours, but check with the office before planning a same-day round trip. If you and Dr. McMillan agree on surgery, the 3-day plan adds two more days: the procedure, then a post-op check. Arriving the night before means you won’t walk in stiff and rushed. Bring a companion if a procedure could follow, since sedation rules out driving yourself.
Can a family member come with me to the visit in Seneca?
Bringing a family member to the consultation is a good idea, because a second listener catches details you might miss and can help you compare the two opinions on the long drive back to Columbia. If surgery could follow, that person may also be your driver, since sedation rules out driving yourself on procedure day. Ask the office ahead of time how many people can join you in the exam room. Have them bring the question list, too.
What if the two opinions still leave me unsure?
If two careful opinions still leave you unsure, that’s useful information in itself, and it’s reasonable to ask both surgeons what would make the choice clearer, or to seek a third opinion for a planned operation. Ask each one what happens if you wait, what the smallest effective operation would be, and what findings would change their mind. Researchers say better trials on second opinions are still needed, so uncertainty isn’t a sign you’ve done something wrong. If your doctors agree it’s safe to wait, waiting can be a decision too.
How We Reviewed This Page
Written by Steven Lockhart of Healthcare Marketing Group from Synergy Spine Center’s clinical materials and the peer-reviewed studies and government sources listed below, then reviewed for clinical accuracy by Marion R. McMillan, MD. Prices are the practice’s published 2026 bundled cash prices. Travel times are estimates from routing data and the practice’s own published figures, so allow for traffic. We review this page at least once a year and whenever the evidence changes.
What’s new: October 2026, first published.
References
- Ferreira GE, Zadro J, Liu C, Harris IA, Maher CG. Second opinions for spinal surgery: a scoping review. BMC Health Serv Res. 2022;22(1):358. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35300677/
- MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia. Low back pain – acute. U.S. National Library of Medicine. https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/007425.htm
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Cauda Equina Syndrome. OrthoInfo. Peer-reviewed by Thomas Ward Throckmorton, MD, FAAOS. https://www.orthoinfo.org/diseases–conditions/cauda-equina-syndrome
- Lenza M, Buchbinder R, Staples MP, Dos Santos OFP, Brandt RA, Lottenberg CL, Cendoroglo M, Ferretti M. Second opinion for degenerative spinal conditions: an option or a necessity? A prospective observational study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2017;18(1):354. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28818047/
- Martin BI, Mirza SK, Spina N, Spiker WR, Lawrence B, Brodke DS. Trends in Lumbar Fusion Procedure Rates and Associated Hospital Costs for Degenerative Spinal Diseases in the United States, 2004 to 2015. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2019;44(5):369-376. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30074971/
- U.S. Census Bureau. QuickFacts: Columbia city, South Carolina (population estimates, July 1, 2025, V2025). https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/columbiacitysouthcarolina/PST045225