(864) 886-9888 Toll-Free (833) 770-8100 Medicare & BlueCross BlueShield accepted

COOLIEF · Columbia, SC

A knee replacement alternative for Columbia patients who aren’t ready for surgery

Not every Columbia patient with knee arthritis is ready for a new knee, or able to have one. Here’s what COOLIEF can and can’t do for the pain, and when surgery is the wiser call.

Quick Answer

As a knee replacement alternative for Columbia patients, COOLIEF does one job: it can calm arthritic knee pain without an operation by quieting the knee’s pain nerves with cooled radiofrequency. The joint and its cartilage stay as they are. A genicular nerve block tests those nerves first, and when surgery is the better path, you’ll be told.

Key Takeaways

Marion R. McMillan, MD, in a dark suit and tie, seated at his desk in front of bookshelves

  • COOLIEF can ease knee arthritis pain by quieting the genicular nerves, but the joint, its cartilage and the arthritis itself are left exactly as they were before treatment.
  • Per MedlinePlus, knee replacement usually comes after other treatments for knee pain haven’t helped enough, and some Columbia patients have already reached that point.
  • When eight sham-controlled trials of people unable to have knee replacement were pooled, genicular nerve ablation beat sham for pain at 12 weeks, though long-term data are still limited (Barreto and colleagues, 2026).
  • The trials on this page report results at 12 weeks and six months, so none of them can say whether COOLIEF changes when, or whether, you’ll need a new knee.
  • Before COOLIEF is scheduled, a genicular nerve block in Seneca has to show that the knee’s nerves carry your pain; without that response, COOLIEF isn’t the right tool.

Wondering whether your knee is a COOLIEF knee or a replacement knee? Send the imaging you already have.

Send your imaging for review

What does COOLIEF change in an arthritic knee, and what does it leave alone?

COOLIEF changes how strongly the nerves around an arthritic knee report pain, and it leaves the joint itself, worn cartilage included, just as it was. That’s the honest frame for any talk of a knee replacement alternative. The treatment uses cooled radiofrequency, guided by ultrasound at Synergy, to quiet the genicular nerves. Those are small sensory nerves that relay pain out of the knee. No cut is made, and nothing stays behind in the joint. You can read more about how COOLIEF works for joint pain in Synergy’s main guide. Maybe you’ve heard the words ‘knee replacement’ sooner than you hoped. If so, COOLIEF can be a non-surgical knee arthritis treatment worth testing. It can’t stand in for a knee replacement when your knee truly needs one.

Part of our guide to
COOLIEF Joint Pain Relief →

Osteoarthritis is a disease of the joints in which tissues gradually break down, and NIAMS lists the knees and hips among the joints it most commonly affects.

What ‘alternative’ can and can’t mean

If you’ve searched for ways to avoid knee replacement or delay knee replacement, the hope behind it makes sense: keep your own knee a while longer. COOLIEF may fit that hope for some people, but only where pain is concerned. The results cited on this page describe pain at 12 weeks and six months. None of them speak to whether treated knees needed a knee replacement later, or when. So the fair way to describe COOLIEF is as a pain treatment you might use while you and your doctors think about the joint, not as care for the joint. For background on the disease, see Synergy’s knee osteoarthritis page. The CDC puts the number of U.S. adults with osteoarthritis at about 33 million, and notes that risk climbs with age (CDC on osteoarthritis).

How strong is the evidence for knee arthritis nerve treatment?

The evidence for knee arthritis nerve treatment is solid in the short term and thin after that: sham-controlled trials show genicular nerve ablation eases pain at 12 weeks, while long-term data remain limited. A sham procedure looks and feels like the real one, but no nerves are treated. That makes it a demanding test. A 2026 meta-analysis pooled eight of those trials: 627 patients in total, all with knee osteoarthritis and all considered ineligible for joint replacement. Against sham, ablation lowered pain at the 12-week mark and helped function, and no serious adverse events turned up (Barreto and colleagues, 2026). One finding deserves a plain reading. In a subgroup analysis, conventional monopolar radiofrequency came out ahead of the other methods. COOLIEF is a cooled method, so this review supports the general approach more than COOLIEF in particular. Synergy’s genicular nerve block page for Columbia patients explains how the knee’s nerves are tested first.

What the two COOLIEF knee trials compared

The two COOLIEF trials cited here compared it with injections, not a sham. That answers a practical question. Does it beat the shot you might otherwise get? Davis and colleagues randomized 151 adults whose knee osteoarthritis pain hadn’t responded to conservative care. Half a year later, 74.1% of the cooled radiofrequency group reported their pain down by half or more, against 16.2% of the steroid group (the Davis 2018 trial). In the Chen trial, a person had to get at least 50% relief from diagnostic genicular blocks before being randomized at all. Among those, 71% of the cooled radiofrequency group hit the halfway mark by six months, versus 38% after hyaluronic acid (the Chen 2020 trial). Neither trial found serious adverse events tied to the procedures. Neither can tell you whether COOLIEF changes your odds of knee replacement down the line.

Who is better served by knee replacement than by COOLIEF?

MedlinePlus says knee replacement is generally done once other treatments for knee pain haven’t helped enough. It’s also more common in older people (MedlinePlus on knee replacement). NIAMS adds that surgery may come into the picture if other treatments haven’t worked. If you’ve worked through injections, therapy and medicine and your knee still runs your days, knee replacement belongs in the conversation. A nerve treatment can’t rebuild a worn joint, and when a block doesn’t ease your pain, other options, surgery included, deserve a closer look. Here’s a situation where the test points that way.

Problem

The Problem

Knee pain has outlasted injections and therapy, and a surgeon in Columbia has now recommended knee replacement. The hope is that a nerve treatment could mean skipping the operation, or at least putting it off.

Solution

The Solution

The imaging goes in for a free review. In Seneca, a genicular nerve block briefly numbs the nerves around the knee to see whether the usual pain eases, and the result is read honestly either way.

Resolution

The Resolution

A clear response makes COOLIEF a reasonable next step. A weak one is useful too: it suggests the knee’s nerves aren’t the main story, sending the decision back to your surgeon without paying for a treatment unlikely to help.

How could a Columbia patient use 90 days to make the knee replacement decision?

Ninety days gives you room to gather facts before a decision you can’t undo. Knee replacement stays available the whole time. The plan below starts at home, moves to Seneca only if the review supports it, and ends back in Columbia with a record of how your knee actually did. Dates shift with scheduling and, if you use it, insurance.

Days 1–30

Collect your knee records

Ask your Columbia doctors for recent knee X-rays or MRI images, the written reports and any surgical recommendation. Send them for the free review. If COOLIEF doesn’t look reasonable, you’ll hear that before any travel is planned.

Days 31–60

Test the nerves in Seneca

After an in-person consultation, the genicular nerve block checks whether those nerves carry your pain. Pay attention to stairs, standing up and walking while it works. If relief is clear, COOLIEF can follow, on the same trip or a later one.

Days 61–90

Weigh the results at home

Back in Columbia, note your walking distance, your sleep and the way stairs feel. Share those notes with your orthopedic surgeon. Real numbers from your own knee make the knee replacement conversation more concrete, whichever way it goes.

An older man leaning on a cane with one hand on his hip while his wife, holding a book, reaches toward him

Ask about a genicular nerve block in Seneca before you make a final call on surgery.

Request a COOLIEF evaluation

Which path fits your knee: testing COOLIEF or planning a knee replacement?

The right question isn’t which treatment is strongest. It’s which one fits the knee you have right now. So the table starts from your situation instead of from the treatments. Every row leans on a source cited on this page, and none of it replaces an exam. For a closer look at COOLIEF in the knee, Synergy’s page on COOLIEF for knee osteoarthritis goes further, and the bundled price is laid out on the COOLIEF cost page for Columbia patients.

Matching your knee situation to a path
Where you are What it points toward Why
Pain is the main problem, and you’re not ready for surgery Testing COOLIEF, starting with a genicular nerve block COOLIEF works on pain signals, and the block shows whether those nerves carry yours.
Other treatments, nerve treatment included, haven’t helped enough A knee replacement conversation with an orthopedic surgeon That’s when knee replacement is usually done, per MedlinePlus.
You’ve been told you can’t have surgery Nerve treatment may still be worth testing Sham-controlled trials in people ineligible for knee replacement showed less pain at 12 weeks (Barreto 2026).
The genicular block doesn’t ease your usual pain Not COOLIEF The knee’s nerves probably aren’t the main source. Other options, surgery included, come back into view.
Your goal is to repair or restore the joint Not COOLIEF COOLIEF doesn’t repair cartilage. Surgery is what addresses the joint itself.

Two rows say ‘Not COOLIEF,’ and that’s deliberate. A pain treatment is the wrong tool when the block shows the nerves aren’t the source, or when what you want is a repaired joint. Read the other way, the table also shows where COOLIEF is a fair option to test: knee pain when surgery isn’t an option, or when you’re not ready for it. You may fit more than one row. That’s normal, and sorting it out is exactly what the free review and the block are for.

What should a Columbia patient expect on the trip to Seneca for knee COOLIEF?

Plan on about 2½ to 3 hours on the road from Columbia, on I-26 to I-385, then US-123, with no state border along the way. Dr. McMillan has practiced in the Upstate since 1992, and he’s board certified in both internal medicine and anesthesiology. Air travel isn’t much help for this trip. Columbia Metropolitan Airport (CAE) is just as far from Seneca by road, about 2½ to 3 hours, and the Greenville-Spartanburg airport (GSP) is about an hour out. Arthritis of every kind is common in South Carolina. The CDC’s 2023 indicators put the state’s age-adjusted share of adults with diagnosed arthritis at 25.2% (CDC arthritis indicator), a figure that also counts gout, lupus and fibromyalgia.

Getting to Seneca from Columbia
Drive to the practice About 2½ to 3 hours by car via I-26 to I-385, then US-123, depending on traffic and where you start.
Nearest major airport to Seneca Greenville-Spartanburg International Airport (GSP), about an hour away by car.
From CAE Columbia Metropolitan Airport is about 2½ to 3 hours from the practice by car.
Before you travel Free MRI review of the imaging you already have. If you aren’t a candidate, you won’t be asked to travel.
Where you’ll be seen Synergy Spine Center & Physician Group P.A., 457-E Bypass 123, Seneca, SC 29678

Plan the trip around the test

The block is only useful if you can tell whether your usual pain has eased. So before you leave Columbia, note which movements reliably hurt: stairs, rising from a chair, the first steps after sitting. A long stretch in the car can leave an arthritic knee stiffer than normal, and that muddies the comparison. Take a break partway to walk. Then give yourself time to loosen up before the appointment. Ask the office whether the block and COOLIEF can share one visit or need two. If sedation is part of the plan, bring someone to drive you back to Columbia. Synergy’s Columbia patient page is a good next stop for travel questions.

About these prices. Bundled cash prices include the $250 initial consultation (credited to the surgeon fee if the procedure is performed), surgeon, anesthesia, facility and routine post-op follow-up. Pre-op labs, imaging, pathology and additional diagnostics are billed separately. If insurance is filed, these prices do not apply. The COOLIEF diagnostic block is billed separately from the COOLIEF procedure. Insurance is also accepted. Coverage depends on your plan; check before you book travel. Figures are the practice’s published 2026 rates. See the pricing disclaimer.

The Bottom Line

The honest version: COOLIEF treats knee pain, not the knee. When a genicular nerve block shows those nerves carry your pain, it’s a reasonable thing to try while you hold off on surgery you aren’t ready for. When it doesn’t, knee replacement deserves a fresh look. From Columbia, step one is free: send your knee imaging for review.

Still deciding about surgery? Send your knee imaging from Columbia and find out whether the trip makes sense.

Prefer to talk first? Call (833) 770-8100 toll-free.

Ask about COOLIEF

Frequently Asked Questions

Will COOLIEF mean I never need a new knee?

COOLIEF offers no assurance against a future knee replacement, because it eases pain signals from an arthritic knee without repairing cartilage or changing the joint, so it doesn’t decide whether a worn knee eventually needs surgery. What it can offer is relief for people whose genicular block shows those nerves carry the pain. That relief can make it easier to stay active while you decide. Sometimes the block doesn’t help, which is useful to learn before choosing surgery. Either way, the joint itself is unchanged.

Can COOLIEF delay knee replacement?

COOLIEF hasn’t been shown in the research cited here to delay knee replacement, because the results describe pain at 12 weeks and six months, not how many people later had surgery. A stretch of relief can give you time with a decision you aren’t ready to make yet. Think of that as time with less pain, not time that protects the joint. Talk with your orthopedic surgeon about what waiting means for your knee.

Does nerve treatment help people who can’t have knee surgery?

Nerve treatment can help some people who can’t have knee surgery, since a 2026 meta-analysis pooling eight sham-controlled trials in that exact group found less knee pain at 12 weeks with genicular nerve ablation than with sham. Function was better as well, and the pooled trials showed no serious adverse events (the 2026 Barreto meta-analysis). The catch is time, since long-term data are limited. That makes nerve treatment a reasonable option to explore for knee pain when surgery isn’t an option, with clear expectations. A genicular nerve block would still come first.

If I try COOLIEF first, can I still have a knee replacement later?

COOLIEF works on nerves rather than on the joint’s structure, so trying it first leaves the knee replacement decision open for later, whether relief falls short, fades or never arrives. Any surgeon you see later should know you’ve had it, so keep a record of the date and which knee was treated. Before the procedure, the genicular nerve block helps show whether it’s worth trying at all. If replacement looks like the wiser path from the start, the free review will say so. That way you’re not spending time or money on a detour.

What does COOLIEF for one knee cost, and what does the Columbia trip add?

The bundled cash price for COOLIEF on one knee at Synergy is $3,000, and the genicular nerve block before it carries its own separate charge, quoted ahead of time so you know it before planning the drive from Columbia. Imaging, lab work and any added diagnostics are charged separately. Insurance is also accepted. Synergy takes Medicare, among other plans. Cash prices don’t apply when insurance is billed. Travel costs are yours to plan: fuel, meals and maybe a night in Seneca. Synergy’s knee COOLIEF pricing page has the full breakdown.

Should my orthopedic surgeon in Columbia know I’m looking into COOLIEF?

Yes, keeping your orthopedic surgeon in Columbia informed makes sense, because COOLIEF treats pain while the joint itself, and any decision about replacing it, remains part of your orthopedic care. Send their notes and imaging reports with your free review, including any recommendation for surgery. If you go ahead, share the dates and your relief log with them afterward. Ongoing care for the joint can stay with the doctors you already see at home. Keeping both sides informed avoids mixed messages.

Is the drive from Columbia hard on an arthritic knee?

The drive from Columbia to Seneca takes about 2½ to 3 hours, and sitting that long can leave an arthritic knee stiff, so plan at least one stop to stand, walk and let the joint loosen before you arrive. The route runs I-26 to I-385, then US-123, all inside South Carolina. If sedation is planned, someone else will need to drive home, which also lets you stretch the leg out. Arriving a little early gives the knee time to settle before the block, so the test reflects your usual pain.

Is COOLIEF FDA-approved?

COOLIEF isn’t FDA-approved; it’s FDA-cleared, and the agency’s 510(k) file K163461 shows the COOLIEF Cooled RF Probe received that clearance on April 13, 2017, which is a different pathway from approval. You can look up the entry yourself in the FDA 510(k) database. People sometimes use the words interchangeably, but they aren’t the same thing. Neither one tells you how your own knee will respond. The trials described on this page are a more useful guide to what the treatment can and can’t do.

How We Reviewed This Page

Written by Steven Lockhart of Healthcare Marketing Group from Synergy Spine Center’s clinical materials and the peer-reviewed studies and government sources listed below, then reviewed for clinical accuracy by Marion R. McMillan, MD. Prices are the practice’s published 2026 bundled cash prices. Travel times are estimates from routing data and the practice’s own published figures, so allow for traffic. We review this page at least once a year and whenever the evidence changes.

What’s new: October 2026, first published.

References

  1. MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia. Knee pain. U.S. National Library of Medicine. https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/003187.htm
  2. MedlinePlus. Knee Replacement. U.S. National Library of Medicine. https://medlineplus.gov/kneereplacement.html
  3. Barreto RB, Barreto AJ, do Nascimento ALM, Carvalho DMB, Queiroz B. Efficacy and safety of genicular nerve ablation techniques for knee osteoarthritis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of sham-controlled randomized trials. Pain Med. 2026;27(4):449-461. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41063397/
  4. National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases. Osteoarthritis. https://www.niams.nih.gov/health-topics/osteoarthritis
  5. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Osteoarthritis. https://www.cdc.gov/arthritis/osteoarthritis/index.html
  6. Davis T, Loudermilk E, DePalma M, Hunter C, Lindley D, Patel N, Choi D, Soloman M, Gupta A, Desai M, Buvanendran A, Kapural L. Prospective, Multicenter, Randomized, Crossover Clinical Trial Comparing the Safety and Effectiveness of Cooled Radiofrequency Ablation With Corticosteroid Injection in the Management of Knee Pain From Osteoarthritis. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2018;43(1):84-91. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29095245/
  7. Chen AF, Khalouf F, Zora K, DePalma M, Kohan L, Guirguis M, Beall D, Loudermilk E, Pingree M, Badiola I, Lyman J. Cooled Radiofrequency Ablation Compared with a Single Injection of Hyaluronic Acid for Chronic Knee Pain: A Multicenter, Randomized Clinical Trial Demonstrating Greater Efficacy and Equivalent Safety for Cooled Radiofrequency Ablation. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2020;102(17):1501-1510. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32898379/
  8. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. U.S. Chronic Disease Indicators: Arthritis among adults (BRFSS), 2023 data. https://www.cdc.gov/cdi/definitions/arthritis.html
  9. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. 510(k) Premarket Notification K163461: Coolief Cooled RF Probe (Halyard Health). Decision date April 13, 2017. https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfpmn/pmn.cfm?ID=K163461
Medical DisclaimerThis content is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider with questions about a medical condition. Individual results vary.

AI Assistant Online

Schedule a Consultation

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Request Sent!

We've received your request and will be in touch within 24 hours.

Something went wrong