(864) 886-9888 Toll-Free (833) 770-8100 Medicare & BlueCross BlueShield accepted
Fusion Alternative

Adjacent Segment Disease: The Problem That Shows Up Years Later

A fusion takes motion out of one segment, and the segments next to it absorb what that one used to do. Sometimes, years later, those neighbors start to complain.

Needle placement for a diagnostic facet block
Needle placement for a diagnostic facet block — Synergy Spine Center, Seneca, South Carolina.
Quick answer

Adjacent segment disease is degeneration and symptoms that develop in the mobile spinal levels immediately above or below a fusion. Once a segment is fused, the neighboring levels carry extra load and motion, and over years that can produce new disc herniation, narrowing or arthritis at those levels. Not everyone who has a fusion develops it.

Key takeaways

  • Adjacent segment disease is new trouble in the mobile levels next to a fused segment, typically appearing years after the original operation.
  • Fusion eliminates motion at one segment, and the levels above and below take on more load and more movement as a result.
  • Changes visible on imaging next to a fusion are common; symptoms are a separate question, and only symptoms get treated.
  • New arm or leg pain years after a fusion deserves a fresh look at the imaging rather than an assumption that the fusion failed.
  • When a nerve next to a fusion is compressed, a decompression that preserves motion may be an option — it depends on the anatomy and on the hardware already there.
  • If you have sudden weakness, numbness in the groin or inner thighs, or loss of bladder or bowel control, seek emergency care immediately.
▸

What is adjacent segment disease?

Adjacent segment disease is the development of symptomatic degeneration in the mobile spinal level immediately above or below a fused segment. The distinction clinicians draw is between adjacent segment degeneration, which means changes visible on imaging, and adjacent segment disease, which means those changes are actually producing symptoms. Plenty of people have the first without ever having the second, and that difference is the single most useful thing to understand about this topic.

To see why it happens, you have to be clear about what a fusion does. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons describes spinal fusion as a procedure that joins two or more vertebrae so that motion between them is eliminated — bone graft or a spacer fills the space, hardware usually holds the segment still while bone grows across it, and once that bone knits the segment behaves as one piece. When it works, it works: a segment that was moving abnormally stops moving abnormally.

But your lumbar spine still has to bend forward when you tie your shoes, and your neck still has to turn when you reverse the car. If one segment no longer contributes to that movement, the movement has to come from somewhere, and the obvious somewhere is the levels immediately next door. They move a little more than they used to, under a little more load, several thousand times a day, for years. Over a long enough period, some of them show it.

None of this makes fusion the wrong operation when it is the right operation. A spine that is genuinely unstable needs stabilization, and the alternative to a necessary fusion is not a healthier spine but an unstable one. The point of this article is narrower: to explain a known long-term trade-off clearly enough that you can factor it into a decision you have not made yet, or recognize it if you are living with it now.

Adjacent segment degeneration
Wear visible on imaging in the mobile level immediately above or below a fusion, which may or may not be causing any symptoms.
Adjacent segment disease
Adjacent segment degeneration that has become symptomatic — producing pain, numbness or weakness that can be traced to that level.
Diagram of the endoscopic approaches used to reach a herniated disc
Diagram of the endoscopic approaches used to reach a herniated disc — Synergy Spine Center, Seneca, SC.

Why do the levels next to a fusion wear out faster?

The levels next to a fusion wear faster because they absorb the motion and the mechanical load the fused segment no longer handles. Think of a chain in which one link has been welded solid. The chain still has to flex the same total amount to do the same job, so the links on either side of the weld flex further than they were built to. In the spine, that extra work falls on the disc, the facet joints and the ligaments of the neighboring level.

Three changes tend to follow, over years rather than months. The disc at that level loses height and water content and becomes less able to distribute load. The facet joints at the back of the segment, which guide and limit motion, carry more of the load and develop arthritic change. And the ligaments can thicken, which narrows the space around the nerves. Any of the three can produce symptoms; often it is a combination.

It is important to be careful here, because this is exactly where health content tends to overreach. Discs degenerate in people who have never had surgery at all. The National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases, writing about back pain, notes that degenerative changes are a common part of aging and that imaging findings often do not correspond to symptoms. So when a level next to a fusion looks worn on a scan, there is genuine scientific difficulty in separating what the fusion caused from what time would have caused anyway.

What can be said responsibly is this: the biomechanical explanation is well established and uncontroversial, the imaging changes next to fusions are frequently observed, and only a portion of those changes ever become symptomatic. Anyone quoting you a precise percentage for how often this happens is reporting one study’s definition of the term rather than a settled number.

A fused segment stops moving, but your spine still has to bend the same amount. The motion has to come from somewhere, and the neighbors are the obvious somewhere.The mechanism in one sentence

New pain years after a fusion? Have the imaging read before you assume the worst.

Start your free MRI review

Does everyone who has a fusion end up with this problem?

No — many people live for decades with a fusion and never develop symptoms at the neighboring levels. That is worth stating first, because the topic is easy to read as a prophecy, and it is not one. A fusion done for a clear indication, in the right patient, at the right number of levels, is a durable operation and a great many people are glad they had it.

Several things appear to influence the risk, and they follow logically from the mechanism. The number of levels fused matters, because each fused level transfers more work to the remaining mobile ones. The condition of the neighboring discs at the time of surgery matters, since a level already degenerating has less reserve. Age, overall spinal alignment and the demands you place on your back all enter the picture too. So does the simple passage of time: this is a problem that shows up years out, not weeks out.

The practical implication of the mechanism is a preference, not a rule: where a problem can be solved without eliminating motion, there is an argument for solving it that way. That is the reasoning behind the practice’s approach to endoscopic spine surgery, which removes the herniation or the narrowing pressing on the nerve and leaves the segment free to move, with no screws, rods, plates or fusion left behind. Randomized controlled trials comparing full-endoscopic and conventional microsurgical techniques have found comparable results for many herniated discs and cases of stenosis, with fewer complications.

The honest limit on that argument is that a decompression cannot stabilize an unstable spine. If motion is the problem, removing more tissue does not fix it. The choice between the two operations is decided by what your imaging and examination actually show, not by which trade-off sounds more appealing in the abstract.

Degeneration versus disease next to a fusion
Adjacent segment degenerationAdjacent segment disease
What it describesChanges visible on imagingChanges that are producing symptoms
How it is foundOn a scan, often incidentallyOn a scan, matched to a matching symptom and examination
How commonFrequently observed next to fusionsOnly a portion of degeneration ever becomes symptomatic
Does it need treatmentGenerally noPossibly, depending on severity and on what has failed
What drives the decisionNothing — it is a findingYour symptoms, your examination and your function
Risk of acting on it aloneOperating on a picture rather than a problemThe usual surgical risks, weighed against real symptoms
New pain after a fusion: what else it could be
Possible sourceTypical patternHow it is sorted out
Adjacent level nerve compressionNew arm or leg pain in a specific nerve distribution after a good symptom-free periodImaging of the level above or below, matched to the examination
Nonunion of the original fusionPain that never fully resolved after the first operationImaging assessment of whether the fusion is solid
Instability at the neighboring levelMechanical pain worse with movement, better with restFlexion and extension views showing movement between vertebrae
Facet arthritis at the adjacent levelAching back or neck pain, often worse with extensionExamination plus, in some cases, a diagnostic block
Referred pain from a hip or shoulderPain in the buttock, groin or upper arm without a clear nerve patternExamination of that joint, and imaging if indicated

How do you know if new pain is coming from the segment next to a fusion?

New pain years after a fusion needs a fresh evaluation, not an assumption, because several different problems produce similar symptoms. The pain could be coming from the level above or below. It could be coming from the fusion itself if the bone never fully knitted. It could be hardware-related, muscular, or referred from a hip. Each of those has a different answer, and the only way through is to look rather than guess.

Certain patterns raise the question. A long symptom-free period after the original surgery, followed by a gradual return of pain, points toward something new rather than something unresolved. Pain that travels down an arm or a leg in a specific distribution suggests a compressed nerve root at a particular level, and that level can be identified. Pain that is worse when you stand and walk and eases when you sit or lean forward is the pattern of narrowing around the nerves.

The investigation usually starts with the imaging you already have, read against the symptoms you actually describe. Flexion and extension views can show whether a neighboring segment has become unstable. And the fusion itself can be assessed to see whether it is solid. The sequence below is the one the practice uses, and it is built so that you learn where you stand before committing to anything.

  1. Gather the records from your original surgery — the operative report if you can get it, and the levels that were fused.
  2. Request your most recent imaging and the written radiology report from the facility that performed it; you are entitled to copies of both.
  3. Write down the timeline precisely: when you felt well after the first operation, when the new symptoms started, and how they have changed since.
  4. Submit the imaging through the practice’s secure online MRI review tool, which costs nothing and which the team will walk you through.
  5. Have the images read against your symptoms, so that any finding next to the fusion is matched to the pain you actually have.
  6. If a motion-preserving decompression can reach the problem, discuss it; if it cannot, you will be told that plainly rather than talked into it.

What are the treatment options for adjacent segment disease?

Treatment depends entirely on what is causing the symptoms, and it ranges from conservative care through targeted injections to surgery on the affected level. Most people start with the non-surgical options, and they are not a formality: physical therapy aimed at the specific mechanics of a spine with a fused segment, activity modification, and time all genuinely help some people. Nothing here is urgent unless there is weakness or a red-flag symptom.

When a nerve root next to a fusion is clearly compressed and conservative care has not resolved it, the surgical question becomes which operation can reach the problem. The traditional answer has often been to extend the fusion by one level, which solves the compression and, by the same logic this article has been describing, transfers the load one level further along. That is sometimes genuinely the right answer, particularly where the adjacent level has become unstable.

The other answer is a decompression that preserves motion. Full-endoscopic spine surgery works through a pencil-sized lighted tube passed through an incision of less than half an inch, removing the herniation or the narrowing that is pressing on the nerve, with nothing left behind in the spine. The procedure typically takes about an hour, is performed on an outpatient basis — often under local anesthesia with light sedation — and most patients go home the same day, often within a few hours. Many notice relief within two to five days with continued improvement over the following weeks, though individual results vary.

Whether that approach can be used next to an existing fusion is an anatomical question, not a philosophical one. It depends on the level involved, the approach angle available, and the hardware already in place. The way to find out is to have the imaging read by someone who performs the smaller operation, because a practice that only fuses can only offer you a fusion.

Don't wait on these

Go to an emergency department the same day for sudden or progressing weakness in a leg or an arm, a foot that drops, numbness in the groin or inner thighs, or any loss of bladder or bowel control. MedlinePlus lists loss of bladder or bowel control among the symptoms needing urgent assessment, and the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons describes cauda equina syndrome as a surgical emergency. A second opinion can wait a week. These cannot wait at all.

What mistakes do people make with adjacent segment disease?

The most common mistake is assuming new pain means the first operation failed. In many cases the original fusion did exactly what it was meant to do, and the new problem is at a different level entirely. Those two situations call for completely different responses, and conflating them leads people either to despair about surgery in general or to accept a revision they may not need.

The second mistake is the mirror image: treating an imaging report as a diagnosis. Degenerative change above a fusion is a common finding and is frequently silent. A finding that does not explain your symptoms is not the finding to operate on. MedlinePlus, from the National Library of Medicine, makes the same point about a herniated disk — many are found on imaging in people with no symptoms at all, and treatment is directed at symptoms rather than at pictures.

The third mistake is assuming the only option is more fusion. It may be. It may not be. The question of whether a motion-preserving decompression can reach the problem is answerable from your imaging, and getting that answer costs you a delay of days. The practice’s work in minimally invasive spine surgery exists precisely for the cases where it can.

The fourth mistake is waiting through progressive weakness. Deliberate, informed patience is good medicine for most spinal pain. A foot that is beginning to drop, or weakness that is measurably worse than last month, is a different matter and needs prompt assessment. If you are earlier in the process and still weighing a first fusion, the companion pieces on questions to ask before agreeing to a fusion and on whether you really need a spinal fusion are the place to start.

Key terms

Nonunion
A fusion in which the bone has not fully grown across the segment, so the intended solid union was never achieved.
Facet joints
The paired joints at the back of each spinal segment that guide and limit movement; they develop arthritis like any other joint.
Foraminal stenosis
Narrowing of the bony opening where a nerve root exits the spine, which can compress that root without narrowing the central canal.
Radiculopathy
Pain, numbness or weakness traveling along the path of a specific nerve root, caused by pressure or irritation at that root.
Flexion and extension views
X-rays taken while bending forward and leaning back, used to show whether one vertebra moves abnormally relative to the next.

What does it look like to sort out new pain above an old fusion?

The problem

Your fusion was years ago and it worked. You got your life back, you stopped thinking about your spine, and then a familiar kind of pain started again — this time running down the other leg. The first thought is the worst one: that the surgery failed and you are back at the beginning, facing the same operation and the same recovery.

The solution

Instead of assuming, you have your imaging read against your symptoms by a practice that performs the smaller operation. The review tells you which level the new pain is actually coming from, whether the old fusion is solid, and whether the nerve that is being compressed can be reached without fusing again. The review costs nothing and you travel nowhere to get it.

The resolution

You end up with a specific problem instead of a vague dread. For some people the answer is that a nerve at the level above can be decompressed endoscopically, with no hardware added and a same-day discharge. For others the answer is that the adjacent level has become unstable and genuinely needs stabilization, which is a harder answer but a true one. Individual results vary, and either way the next decision is made on evidence.

Send your MRI for a no-cost review and find out whether a motion-preserving option could reach the level that’s causing trouble.

Send your MRI for a free review
About the author
Marion R. McMillan, MD
Marion R. McMillan, MD
Founder & Medical Director, Synergy Spine Center · Seneca, South Carolina

Dr. McMillan graduated from Yale and took his medical degree at Tufts, trained in Naval and university hospitals along the Atlantic coast, and has practiced in Upstate South Carolina since 1992. He is board-certified in Internal Medicine and Anesthesiology with a fellowship in Interventional Pain Management, holds two United States patents in minimally invasive spinal technique, and has published peer-reviewed papers and chapters in endoscopic-spine textbooks.

Full-endoscopic spine surgeryInterventional pain management Spinal stenosisHerniated discTransparent surgical pricing
Clinical accuracy
Marion R. McMillan, MD
Reviewed by Marion R. McMillan, MD
Clinical review completed 2026-10-29

Every clinical statement in this article was checked against the practice’s own published materials and the primary sources listed below. Where the evidence is mixed or an outcome varies between patients, the article says so rather than rounding it off.

How we keep this accurate

We cite primary sources — government health agencies, peer-reviewed literature and recognized clinical bodies — for every medical claim, and we do not publish statistics we cannot trace. Pricing reflects the practice’s published list at the time of review and is subject to change; see the current price list. This article was published 2026-10-29 and is reviewed on an ongoing basis.

Sources

  1. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (OrthoInfo). Spinal Fusion. https://orthoinfo.aaos.org/en/treatment/spinal-fusion/
  2. National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases. Back Pain. https://www.niams.nih.gov/health-topics/back-pain
  3. MedlinePlus, U.S. National Library of Medicine. Herniated Disk. https://medlineplus.gov/herniateddisk.html
Medical disclaimer. This article is for general education and is not medical advice. It does not create a doctor–patient relationship. Spine and joint conditions differ from person to person, and outcomes vary. Talk with a qualified clinician about your own imaging, symptoms and options before making a treatment decision. If you have sudden weakness, numbness in the groin or inner thighs, or loss of bladder or bowel control, seek emergency care immediately — those can be signs of cauda equina syndrome, which the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons describes as a surgical emergency.

Frequently asked questions

What is adjacent segment disease, in plain terms?
Adjacent segment disease is new wear and new symptoms in the mobile spinal level directly above or below a segment that was fused, usually appearing years rather than months after the original operation. The fused segment no longer moves, so the neighboring levels take on more motion and more load, and over time the disc, the facet joints and the ligaments at those levels can change. The key word is symptoms: changes seen on a scan without symptoms are called adjacent segment degeneration and generally need no treatment at all.
Does every fusion cause adjacent segment disease?
No, and this is important, because many people live for decades after a fusion without ever developing symptoms at the neighboring levels, and a fusion done for a clear indication remains a durable and worthwhile operation. The number of levels fused, the condition of the neighboring discs at the time of surgery, your alignment and your activities all appear to influence the risk. Anyone quoting a precise percentage is reporting one study's particular definition rather than a settled figure.
How long after a fusion does it usually appear?
It is characteristically a long-term development, measured in years rather than weeks, which is one of the features that distinguishes it from problems with the original operation itself. Pain that never resolved after a fusion points toward something else, such as a fusion that did not fully knit or a nerve that was never adequately decompressed. A long symptom-free period followed by new pain in a new distribution is the pattern that raises the question of the adjacent level.
Can endoscopic surgery be done next to an existing fusion?
Sometimes, and whether it can is an anatomical question answered from your imaging rather than a matter of general policy, since it depends on the level involved, the working angle available and the hardware already in place. Where a nerve root at the adjacent level is compressed by a herniation or by narrowing, a full-endoscopic decompression may be able to reach it without adding hardware or extending the fusion. The way to find out is to have the imaging reviewed by a practice that performs that operation.
Will I just need another fusion?
Not necessarily, because extending a fusion by one level is one option among several and is most clearly indicated when the adjacent segment has become genuinely unstable rather than simply compressed. If the problem is pressure on a nerve, a decompression that preserves motion may address it. If the problem is abnormal movement, decompression alone will not solve it and stabilization is the honest answer. Your flexion and extension imaging is usually what separates those two situations.
How is adjacent segment disease diagnosed?
It is diagnosed by matching a finding on imaging at the level next to a fusion with symptoms and an examination that point to that same level, rather than by the scan alone. Your clinician will want the timeline — when you were well, when the symptoms started, how they have progressed — and will look for a nerve distribution that corresponds to a specific level. Flexion and extension views may be added to assess movement, and the original fusion is assessed to confirm it is solid.
Can anything prevent it?
Nothing is proven to prevent it outright, but the mechanism suggests some reasonable principles: fuse only what genuinely needs fusing, fuse as few levels as the problem requires, and prefer a motion-preserving solution when one can actually address the problem. General spinal health helps too — staying active, maintaining strength, and avoiding long periods of deconditioning. None of this is a guarantee against degeneration, which also occurs in spines that have never been operated on at all.
Is it worth getting a second opinion about this?
Yes, and it is routine rather than rude, because reasonable clinicians read the same images differently and a revision fusion is a significant commitment that deserves more than one reading. Synergy Spine Center offers a no-cost review of your existing MRI, done from wherever you are, and will tell you plainly if you are not a candidate for a less invasive option. Out-of-state and international patients are welcome, and the practice will not ask you to travel unless you are a candidate.
Editor’s summary

Adjacent segment disease is symptomatic wear in the mobile spinal level immediately above or below a fusion. Because a fused segment no longer moves, its neighbors carry more motion and more load, and over years some of them change. Imaging findings next to a fusion are common; symptoms are a separate matter, and only symptoms are treated. New pain years after a fusion deserves a fresh reading of the imaging, since a decompression that preserves motion can sometimes reach the problem without fusing again.

Pain coming back years after a fusion?

Send your MRI for a free review. We'll tell you which level the trouble is at and whether a motion-preserving option could reach it — including when it can't.

Start your free MRI reviewCall (833) 770-8100

Keep reading

AI Assistant Online

Schedule a Consultation

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Request Sent!

We've received your request and will be in touch within 24 hours.

Something went wrong